Templars and Hospitallers as Professed Religious in the Holy Land
160 pages, 6.00 x 9.00 , 2 maps
Paperback | 9780268040581 | November 2009
The Templars and the Hospitallers were the two earliest and most famous of the major Military Orders of the Roman Catholic Church from the early twelfth to the middle of the thirteenth century. In this book, Jonathan Riley-Smith attends to the Templars' and Hospitallers' primary role as religious orders, not as military phenomena or economic powerhouses. In a prologue, four chapters, and an epilogue, Riley-Smith discusses the origins of the orders in dedication to the protection of pilgrims to the Holy Land (Templars) and to the care of the poor and the sick among them (Hospitallers). He examines their traditions and early history, the organization of their communities, modes of governance, and, in the fourth chapter, important differences between the orders and a brief account of their respective fates in the wake of the Crusades. The Templars were eventually persecuted by the Church and the order suppressed. Riley-Smith speculates that the violent end of the order was caused both by jealousy of its wealth and by internal problems of governance that left it vulnerable to accusations of conducting blasphemous rites. The Hospitallers survived in one form or another to the present day; vestiges of the original order inform the contemporary Knights of Malta.
Jonathan Riley-Smith is Dixie Professor Emeritus of Ecclesiastical History at the University of Cambridge. He is the author of many influential books and essays, including The Crusades, Christianity, and Islam.
"In this book, Jonathan Riley-Smith provides an approachable and expert introduction to the two most famous and most active military orders, the Knights Templar and Knights Hospitaller, and their activities in the Levant. It is a first-rate study, energetically and engagingly written by the world's most accomplished historian of the crusades." —Thomas Madden, St. Louis University
"The image of the military orders is mostly dominated by their military, political, or economic role while their spirituality and their religious character are often neglected. This book, from a great authority on crusading and military orders, offers an inspiring new perspective. Its chapters, concise and well-founded studies concentrating on the inner life of Templars and Hospitallers in the Holy Land, will thus contribute to a considerably better understanding of their history." —Juergen Sarnowsky, Universitaet Hamburg
"Jonathan Riley-Smith, Grand Master of Hospitaller studies since the 1960s, offers the first systematic comparison of the two earliest, most famous, and most researched Military Orders—the Temple and the Hospital. Contrasting the Templars' exclusive commitment to warfare with the Hospitaller dedication to the care of the sick and poor as well as to warfare, Riley-Smith persuasively argues that this disparity influenced decisively not only the internal stratification and the governance of the two Orders, but also their chances of survival. The book, which will have a major impact on future studies, amounts also to an act of love for the Hospital." —Benjamin Z. Kedar, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem
"There is no historian better equipped to define the nature of the two great orders of the Hospital and the Temple than Jonathan Riley-Smith. In this concise analysis he brings to bear his great depth of experience not only to show the similarities and differences between the two orders, but also to place them firmly in their contemporary context." —Malcolm Barber, University of Reading, UK
“In Templars and Hospitallers Riley-Smith returns once again to the history of the two oldest and best-known medieval military orders, whose members combined the functions of monks and knights. Riley-Smith’s Templars and Hospitallers, although brief, is yet one more of his significant contributions to the history of the crusades and the medieval military orders. It is a book that no one interested in these topics can afford to ignore.” —The Catholic Historical Review
“Jonathan Riley-Smith’s Conway Lectures, which amount to seventy pages of text together with detailed notes and a considerable bibliography, advance a number of timely and significant proposals. The author is concerned to emphasize differences between the two major international military orders whose members were technically full-professed religious.” —The Journal of Ecclesiastical History
“Jonathan Riley-Smith, one of the leading experts on military-religious orders, outlines in four chapters the history of the two most important and prominent of these institutions—the Templars and the Hospitallers—in the Levant during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. . . . One should be careful using the term masterpiece; yet for this short volume the phrase may well be appropriate.” —Crusades
“. . . while one may disagree with Riley-Smith on this or that point, one cannot treat his opinions lightly; the massive and sympathetic erudition that he brings to bear on his subject ensures that. This is a valuable book—perhaps even because of the disagreements and discussions it may provoke—and belongs in the library of every crusade and military-order historian.” —Church History