Other Roots, The
Wandering Origins in Roots of Brazil and the Impasses of Modernity in Ibero-America
Paperback | 9780268102340 | October 2017
Hardcover | 9780268102333 | October 2017
eBook (PDF) | 9780268102357 | October 2017
eBook (EPUB) | 9780268102364 | October 2017
First published in 1936, the classic work Roots of Brazil by Sérgio Buarque de Holanda presented an analysis of why and how a European culture flourished in a large tropical environment that was totally foreign to its traditions, and the manner and consequences of this development. In The Other Roots, Pedro Meira Monteiro contends that Roots of Brazil is an essential work for understanding Brazil and the current impasses of politics in Latin America. Meira Monteiro demonstrates that the ideas expressed in Roots of Brazil have taken on new forms and helped to construct some of the most lasting images of the country, such as the "cordial man," a central concept that expresses the Ibero-American cultural and political experience and constantly wavers between liberalism's claims to impersonality and deeply ingrained forms of personalism. Meira Monteiro examines in particular how "cordiality" reveals the everlasting conflation of the public and the private spheres in Brazil. Despite its ambivalent relationship to liberal democracy, Roots of Brazil may be seen as part of a Latin Americanist assertion of a shared continental experience, which today might extend to the idea of solidarity across the so-called Global South. Taking its cue from Buarque de Holanda, The Other Roots investigates the reasons why national discourses invariably come up short, and shows identity to be a poetic and political tool, revealing that any collectivity ultimately remains intact thanks to the multiple discourses that sustain it in fragile, problematic, and fascinating equilibrium.
Pedro Meira Monteiro is professor of Spanish and Portuguese at Princeton University. He is the author, editor, and co-editor of numerous books, including a critical edition of Raízes do Brasil.
"Pedro Meira Monteiro has written an invaluable and very necessary book. Taking Sérgio Buarque de Holanda’s classic on Brazilian society and culture as a guide, The Other Roots looks into the survival of Buarque’s ideas to help illuminate the impasses of Latin American political culture in a densely textured and theoretically acute study." ~Florencia Garramuño, University of San Andrés
"This is a book by a restless, curious, and erudite thinker who has dedicated himself to reflecting on the seminal work and figure of Sérgio Buarque de Holanda. The conversation is so elegantly executed, and the results so ringing, that all emerge transformed: Holanda, Meira Monteiro, and the readers themselves." ~Lilia Moritz Schwarcz, University of São Paulo
"The 2012 English translation of the seminal 1936 study by Sérgio Buarque de Holanda Roots of Brazil marked a significant year in the international study of the historiography of Brazil. Meira Monteiro studies the history and impact of the Buarque book, and his book is a valuable companion to Roots." ~Choice
The Other Roots: Wandering Origins in Roots of Brazil and the Impasses of Modernity in Ibero-America is a highly original and rich study of the main topics and contributions of Sérgio Buarque de Holanda's Roots of Brazil. It promotes an essential task, one that not many people undertake: trying to think about Brazil and its culture through its complex links with different intellectual traditions. This explicit, multicultural approach to Brazil is, in my view, a very necessary move for Brazilian studies today. ~Norman Valencia, Claremont McKenna College
“In postmodern fashion, Monteiro captures very well how de Holanda’s rendering of Brazilian identity as cordiality dwells in the tension between opposites.” ~The Review of Politics